An incidental finding of severe carotid stenosis often triggers two questions. Can a procedure lower stroke risk, and will better blood flow improve memory? CREST-2 examined both in patients with at least 70% stenosis and no stroke, transient ischemic attack or transient monocular blindness attributable to that artery in the preceding 180 days. Its answers differ by outcome. [1] [2]
Two trials with separate comparison groups
In one trial, 1,245 patients were randomized to intensive medical management with or without transfemoral carotid stenting. A separate trial assigned 1,240 patients to intensive medical management with or without surgical endarterectomy. Both counted any stroke or death through day 44, then ischemic stroke on the side supplied by the stenosed artery through four years. [1]
At four years, the composite outcome occurred in 2.8% with stenting and 6.0% with medical management alone (absolute difference 3.2 percentage points, P=0.02). The benefit came with an upfront risk. Through day 44, there were seven strokes and one death in the stenting group and none in its medical comparison group. In the surgical trial, the four-year rates were 3.7% with endarterectomy and 5.3% with medical management (P=0.24). Patients were never randomized between the procedures, so these figures cannot rank stenting against surgery. [1]
What to tell patients asking about memory
A 2026 prespecified secondary analysis included 2,165 participants with cognitive data. Testing covered functions including learning, memory and attention. At four years, neither intervention produced a significant advantage on the composite cognitive score over its medical comparison group. An expected improvement in memory is therefore a poor basis for recommending revascularization in this population. [2]
What to take into practice
At referral, document any recent focal neurological or retinal symptoms, review medical prevention, and discuss the center’s own procedural outcomes. CREST-2 used credentialed operators and actively managed vascular risk in every group. Its estimates apply to a different population from patients seen after a recent carotid-territory event. [1]
Sources
Evidence checked on 21 November 2026.
[1] Brott et al. Medical Management and Revascularization for Asymptomatic Carotid Stenosis, New England Journal of Medicine (2025-11-21).
[2] Lazar et al. Cognitive Results of the CREST-2 Randomized Trials, JAMA (2026-09-16).